Head-to-head

CarltonAll-time167–612 drawsSt Kilda head-to-head record

Carlton lead St Kilda 167–61 with 2 draws in 230 games since 1897. Their last meeting, in the 2026 Round 22 at Marvel Stadium, went to Carlton by 44 points. They next meet in the 2027 Round 15, Sun 27 Jun 2027, 3:15pm AEST.

Carlton 167Draws 2St Kilda 61
230Games
5Finals
0Grand Finals
5–5Last 10

Last 10 meetings

YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
2026
9 Aug
Round 22 St Kilda8.14 (62) – 16.10 (106) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 44
2026
2 May
Round 8 Carlton9.15 (69) – 16.12 (108) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 39
2025
9 May
Round 9 St Kilda9.8 (62) – 11.11 (77) CarltonMCGCarlton by 15
2024
25 Aug
Round 24 Carlton11.8 (74) – 11.10 (76) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 2
2023
6 Aug
Round 21 St Kilda8.6 (54) – 10.13 (73) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 19
2023
23 Apr
Round 6 Carlton8.12 (60) – 12.10 (82) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 22
2022
1 July
Round 16 Carlton10.18 (78) – 14.9 (93) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 15
2021
30 July
Round 20 St Kilda12.9 (81) – 18.4 (112) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 31
2020
2 July
Round 5 Carlton8.7 (55) – 11.7 (73) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 18
2019
17 Aug
Round 22 Carlton11.12 (78) – 10.8 (68) St KildaMCGCarlton by 10

Finals meetings

YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1972
30 Sept
Finals Week 4 Carlton16.13 (109) – 13.15 (93) St KildaMCGCarlton by 16
1970
19 Sept
Preliminary Finals Carlton17.21 (123) – 7.19 (61) St KildaMCGCarlton by 62
1929
7 Sept
Finals Week 1 Carlton12.9 (81) – 11.7 (73) St KildaMCGCarlton by 8
1908
19 Sept
Semi-Finals Carlton12.12 (84) – 3.8 (26) St KildaMCGCarlton by 58
1907
14 Sept
Semi-Finals Carlton13.13 (91) – 4.11 (35) St KildaMCGCarlton by 56

Records

Biggest Carlton win 29–169, Round 2 1985 (140 pts)
Biggest St Kilda win 88–196, Round 10 2004 (108 pts)
Highest combined score 284 (88–196, Round 10 2004)
Most common venue Princes Park (90 games)

Every meeting

2020s · 9 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
2026
9 Aug
Round 22 St Kilda8.14 (62) – 16.10 (106) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 44
2026
2 May
Round 8 Carlton9.15 (69) – 16.12 (108) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 39
2025
9 May
Round 9 St Kilda9.8 (62) – 11.11 (77) CarltonMCGCarlton by 15
2024
25 Aug
Round 24 Carlton11.8 (74) – 11.10 (76) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 2
2023
6 Aug
Round 21 St Kilda8.6 (54) – 10.13 (73) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 19
2023
23 Apr
Round 6 Carlton8.12 (60) – 12.10 (82) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 22
2022
1 July
Round 16 Carlton10.18 (78) – 14.9 (93) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 15
2021
30 July
Round 20 St Kilda12.9 (81) – 18.4 (112) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 31
2020
2 July
Round 5 Carlton8.7 (55) – 11.7 (73) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 18
2010s · 16 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
2019
17 Aug
Round 22 Carlton11.12 (78) – 10.8 (68) St KildaMCGCarlton by 10
2019
26 May
Round 10 St Kilda9.14 (68) – 8.7 (55) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 13
2018
13 July
Round 17 St Kilda16.20 (116) – 7.10 (52) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 64
2017
13 May
Round 8 St Kilda12.13 (85) – 10.6 (66) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 19
2016
7 Aug
Round 20 Carlton7.9 (51) – 19.8 (122) St KildaMCGSt Kilda by 71
2016
12 June
Round 12 St Kilda17.8 (110) – 12.6 (78) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 32
2015
25 Apr
Round 4 St Kilda12.9 (81) – 18.13 (121) CarltonWellingtonCarlton by 40
2014
6 July
Round 16 Carlton24.7 (151) – 10.6 (66) St KildaMarvel StadiumCarlton by 85
2014
12 May
Round 8 St Kilda9.15 (69) – 15.11 (101) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 32
2013
13 July
Round 16 Carlton16.14 (110) – 10.14 (74) St KildaMarvel StadiumCarlton by 36
2013
13 May
Round 7 St Kilda11.11 (77) – 9.14 (68) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 9
2012
2 Sept
Round 23 Carlton12.19 (91) – 16.10 (106) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 15
2012
14 May
Round 7 St Kilda19.8 (122) – 14.14 (98) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 24
2011
3 Sept
Round 24 Carlton9.12 (66) – 13.8 (86) St KildaMCGSt Kilda by 20
2011
9 May
Round 7 St Kilda12.9 (81) – 11.18 (84) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 3
2010
10 May
Round 7 St Kilda9.14 (68) – 20.9 (129) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 61
2000s · 15 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
2009
12 June
Round 12 Carlton14.11 (95) – 16.8 (104) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 9
2008
11 July
Round 15 Carlton12.15 (87) – 18.11 (119) St KildaMCGSt Kilda by 32
2008
29 Mar
Round 2 St Kilda19.11 (125) – 12.13 (85) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 40
2007
28 July
Round 17 Carlton15.11 (101) – 16.15 (111) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 10
2007
4 May
Round 6 St Kilda18.17 (125) – 11.16 (82) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 43
2006
21 May
Round 8 Carlton4.10 (34) – 18.18 (126) St KildaMCGSt Kilda by 92
2005
10 July
Round 15 St Kilda23.15 (153) – 11.7 (73) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 80
2004
30 May
Round 10 Carlton13.10 (88) – 31.10 (196) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 108
2003
16 Aug
Round 20 Carlton11.9 (75) – 26.10 (166) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 91
2003
10 May
Round 7 St Kilda16.17 (113) – 15.11 (101) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 12
2002
21 July
Round 16 Carlton14.13 (97) – 22.8 (140) St KildaMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 43
2002
30 Mar
Round 1 St Kilda14.5 (89) – 10.5 (65) CarltonMarvel StadiumSt Kilda by 24
2001
19 Aug
Round 20 St Kilda16.8 (104) – 22.16 (148) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 44
2001
28 Apr
Round 5 Carlton17.23 (125) – 14.8 (92) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 33
2000
13 May
Round 10 St Kilda11.16 (82) – 15.19 (109) CarltonMarvel StadiumCarlton by 27
1990s · 16 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1999
21 Aug
Round 21 Carlton15.16 (106) – 7.3 (45) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 61
1999
30 Apr
Round 6 St Kilda14.15 (99) – 7.16 (58) CarltonMCGSt Kilda by 41
1998
16 Aug
Round 20 Carlton19.20 (134) – 15.14 (104) St KildaMCGCarlton by 30
1998
26 Apr
Round 5 St Kilda13.10 (88) – 9.12 (66) CarltonWaverley ParkSt Kilda by 22
1997
15 June
Round 12 St Kilda16.20 (116) – 12.13 (85) CarltonWaverley ParkSt Kilda by 31
1996
26 May
Round 9 St Kilda9.15 (69) – 13.13 (91) CarltonWaverley ParkCarlton by 22
1995
27 May
Round 9 St Kilda11.14 (80) – 3.6 (24) CarltonWaverley ParkSt Kilda by 56
1994
18 June
Round 13 Carlton22.13 (145) – 10.5 (65) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 80
1993
14 Aug
Round 20 Carlton10.17 (77) – 11.18 (84) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 7
1993
25 Apr
Round 5 St Kilda11.12 (78) – 17.21 (123) CarltonWaverley ParkCarlton by 45
1992
9 Aug
Round 21 St Kilda12.15 (87) – 18.14 (122) CarltonWaverley ParkCarlton by 35
1992
25 Apr
Round 6 Carlton18.13 (121) – 17.11 (113) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 8
1991
10 Aug
Round 21 St Kilda23.17 (155) – 15.11 (101) CarltonWaverley ParkSt Kilda by 54
1991
27 Apr
Round 6 Carlton13.16 (94) – 7.18 (60) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 34
1990
21 July
Round 16 Carlton19.9 (123) – 15.18 (108) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 15
1990
14 Apr
Round 3 St Kilda11.10 (76) – 14.8 (92) CarltonWaverley ParkCarlton by 16
1980s · 19 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1989
19 Aug
Round 20 Carlton20.13 (133) – 20.12 (132) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 1
1989
8 Apr
Round 2 St Kilda13.18 (96) – 13.14 (92) CarltonMoorabbin OvalSt Kilda by 4
1988
9 July
Round 15 St Kilda9.11 (65) – 10.9 (69) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 4
1988
7 May
Round 6 Carlton10.12 (72) – 4.8 (32) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 40
1987
13 June
Round 12 Carlton12.25 (97) – 14.12 (96) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 1
1986
28 June
Round 14 Carlton24.19 (163) – 11.10 (76) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 87
1986
12 Apr
Round 3 St Kilda10.9 (69) – 24.13 (157) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 88
1985
22 June
Round 13 Carlton20.19 (139) – 16.11 (107) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 32
1985
6 Apr
Round 2 St Kilda2.17 (29) – 25.19 (169) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 140
1984
21 July
Round 16 St Kilda16.9 (105) – 13.6 (84) CarltonMoorabbin OvalSt Kilda by 21
1984
5 May
Round 6 Carlton15.14 (104) – 13.12 (90) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 14
1983
6 Aug
Round 19 Carlton25.18 (168) – 8.13 (61) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 107
1983
14 May
Round 8 St Kilda12.17 (89) – 22.13 (145) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 56
1982
10 July
Round 16 Carlton21.13 (139) – 9.9 (63) St KildaWaverley ParkCarlton by 76
1982
1 May
Round 6 St Kilda11.14 (80) – 16.22 (118) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 38
1981
4 July
Round 15 Carlton6.14 (50) – 5.5 (35) St KildaWaverley ParkCarlton by 15
1981
25 Apr
Round 5 St Kilda10.13 (73) – 19.23 (137) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 64
1980
23 Aug
Round 21 St Kilda13.9 (87) – 20.16 (136) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 49
1980
31 May
Round 10 Carlton14.20 (104) – 9.8 (62) St KildaWaverley ParkCarlton by 42
1970s · 22 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1979
11 Aug
Round 19 Carlton22.17 (149) – 6.9 (45) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 104
1979
26 May
Round 8 St Kilda9.10 (64) – 15.13 (103) CarltonWaverley ParkCarlton by 39
1978
2 Sept
Round 22 St Kilda16.10 (106) – 9.12 (66) CarltonMoorabbin OvalSt Kilda by 40
1978
17 June
Round 11 Carlton23.27 (165) – 8.17 (65) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 100
1977
9 July
Round 15 St Kilda17.12 (114) – 18.14 (122) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 8
1977
16 Apr
Round 3 Carlton24.26 (170) – 9.9 (63) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 107
1976
7 Aug
Round 19 Carlton22.19 (151) – 7.8 (50) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 101
1976
22 May
Round 8 St Kilda15.14 (104) – 9.12 (66) CarltonWaverley ParkSt Kilda by 38
1975
19 July
Round 16 Carlton11.22 (88) – 8.27 (75) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 13
1975
3 May
Round 5 St Kilda7.16 (58) – 12.19 (91) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 33
1974
31 Aug
Round 22 St Kilda15.11 (101) – 19.9 (123) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 22
1974
15 June
Round 11 Carlton20.13 (133) – 13.10 (88) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 45
1973
1 Sept
Round 22 Carlton20.15 (135) – 13.9 (87) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 48
1973
16 June
Round 11 St Kilda13.13 (91) – 9.13 (67) CarltonMoorabbin OvalSt Kilda by 24
1972
30 Sept
Finals Week 4 Carlton16.13 (109) – 13.15 (93) St KildaMCGCarlton by 16
1972
12 Aug
Round 19 Carlton13.16 (94) – 10.11 (71) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 23
1972
20 May
Round 8 St Kilda10.12 (72) – 14.15 (99) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 27
1971
17 July
Round 16 St Kilda13.19 (97) – 8.6 (54) CarltonMoorabbin OvalSt Kilda by 43
1971
1 May
Round 5 Carlton13.18 (96) – 11.17 (83) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 13
1970
19 Sept
Preliminary Finals Carlton17.21 (123) – 7.19 (61) St KildaMCGCarlton by 62
1970
18 July
Round 16 Carlton16.14 (110) – 10.11 (71) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 39
1970
2 May
Round 5 St Kilda8.9 (57) – 12.14 (86) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 29
1960s · 17 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1969
28 June
Round 12 Carlton9.12 (66) – 7.12 (54) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 12
1969
5 Apr
Round 1 St Kilda11.13 (79) – 11.16 (82) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 3
1968
22 June
Round 10 St Kilda3.10 (28) – 8.8 (56) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 28
1967
12 Aug
Round 16 Carlton11.7 (73) – 9.8 (62) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 11
1967
13 May
Round 5 St Kilda11.9 (75) – 11.14 (80) CarltonMoorabbin OvalCarlton by 5
1966
23 July
Round 13 Carlton7.15 (57) – 5.11 (41) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 16
1966
30 Apr
Round 2 St Kilda15.17 (107) – 7.12 (54) CarltonMoorabbin OvalSt Kilda by 53
1965
3 July
Round 11 St Kilda12.8 (80) – 10.14 (74) CarltonMoorabbin OvalSt Kilda by 6
1964
15 Aug
Round 17 Carlton6.9 (45) – 8.13 (61) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 16
1964
23 May
Round 6 St Kilda13.19 (97) – 6.13 (49) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 48
1963
3 Aug
Round 13 St Kilda14.12 (96) – 7.13 (55) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 41
1963
27 Apr
Round 2 Carlton7.11 (53) – 6.15 (51) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 2
1962
9 June
Round 8 St Kilda5.13 (43) – 6.10 (46) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 3
1961
8 July
Round 12 Carlton9.8 (62) – 3.12 (30) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 32
1961
15 Apr
Round 1 St Kilda5.8 (38) – 6.12 (48) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 10
1960
30 July
Round 14 Carlton10.12 (72) – 11.17 (83) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 11
1960
7 May
Round 3 St Kilda5.11 (41) – 7.3 (45) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 4
1950s · 16 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1959
11 July
Round 11 Carlton15.21 (111) – 8.18 (66) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 45
1958
2 Aug
Round 15 Carlton8.11 (59) – 7.12 (54) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 5
1958
3 May
Round 4 St Kilda12.21 (93) – 8.7 (55) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 38
1957
29 June
Round 11 Carlton13.14 (92) – 7.13 (55) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 37
1956
21 July
Round 14 Carlton8.18 (66) – 9.12 (66) St KildaPrinces ParkDraw
1956
28 Apr
Round 3 St Kilda9.11 (65) – 13.9 (87) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 22
1955
30 July
Round 15 Carlton11.21 (87) – 3.13 (31) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 56
1955
7 May
Round 4 St Kilda7.22 (64) – 15.9 (99) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 35
1954
3 July
Round 11 Carlton9.16 (70) – 12.10 (82) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 12
1953
15 Aug
Round 16 St Kilda8.15 (63) – 7.16 (58) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 5
1953
23 May
Round 5 Carlton7.10 (52) – 6.7 (43) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 9
1952
23 Aug
Round 18 St Kilda8.8 (56) – 13.14 (92) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 36
1952
31 May
Round 6 Carlton14.10 (94) – 10.13 (73) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 21
1951
23 June
Round 9 St Kilda9.11 (65) – 15.15 (105) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 40
1950
12 Aug
Round 16 Carlton12.11 (83) – 11.17 (83) St KildaPrinces ParkDraw
1950
20 May
Round 5 St Kilda10.14 (74) – 8.7 (55) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 19
1940s · 16 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1949
20 Aug
Round 18 Carlton13.17 (95) – 10.14 (74) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 21
1949
28 May
Round 7 St Kilda8.14 (62) – 14.11 (95) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 33
1948
14 June
Round 9 Carlton12.12 (84) – 7.18 (60) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 24
1947
16 Aug
Round 17 Carlton14.19 (103) – 3.12 (30) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 73
1947
24 May
Round 6 St Kilda7.11 (53) – 23.17 (155) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 102
1946
17 Aug
Round 17 Carlton14.8 (92) – 10.17 (77) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 15
1946
25 May
Round 6 St Kilda10.12 (72) – 22.17 (149) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 77
1945
4 Aug
Round 16 St Kilda7.15 (57) – 11.13 (79) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 22
1945
19 May
Round 5 Carlton12.18 (90) – 11.13 (79) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 11
1944
17 June
Round 7 St Kilda6.12 (48) – 15.13 (103) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 55
1943
5 June
Round 5 St Kilda13.14 (92) – 12.8 (80) CarltonToorak ParkSt Kilda by 12
1942
27 June
Round 8 Carlton18.14 (122) – 10.11 (71) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 51
1941
16 Aug
Round 16 Carlton20.17 (137) – 11.14 (80) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 57
1941
31 May
Round 5 St Kilda13.12 (90) – 15.18 (108) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 18
1940
17 Aug
Round 16 Carlton13.14 (92) – 6.16 (52) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 40
1940
25 May
Round 5 St Kilda6.18 (54) – 11.19 (85) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 31
1930s · 19 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1939
24 June
Round 10 St Kilda14.14 (98) – 9.16 (70) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 28
1938
27 Aug
Round 18 Carlton15.14 (104) – 13.10 (88) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 16
1938
4 June
Round 7 St Kilda6.15 (51) – 12.18 (90) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 39
1937
14 Aug
Round 16 Carlton12.16 (88) – 11.12 (78) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 10
1937
22 May
Round 5 St Kilda12.19 (91) – 13.16 (94) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 3
1936
5 Sept
Round 18 St Kilda16.10 (106) – 15.15 (105) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 1
1936
13 June
Round 7 Carlton19.14 (128) – 11.9 (75) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 53
1935
24 Aug
Round 16 Carlton18.22 (130) – 16.12 (108) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 22
1935
25 May
Round 5 St Kilda16.14 (110) – 20.9 (129) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 19
1934
15 Sept
Round 18 Carlton16.18 (114) – 15.9 (99) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 15
1934
23 June
Round 7 St Kilda16.12 (108) – 24.22 (166) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 58
1933
2 Sept
Round 18 Carlton20.25 (145) – 14.9 (93) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 52
1933
10 June
Round 7 St Kilda10.5 (65) – 20.10 (130) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 65
1932
3 Sept
Round 18 St Kilda7.12 (54) – 20.21 (141) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 87
1932
18 June
Round 7 Carlton17.16 (118) – 7.12 (54) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 64
1931
12 Sept
Round 18 Carlton10.6 (66) – 6.12 (48) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 18
1931
13 June
Round 7 St Kilda8.11 (59) – 12.18 (90) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 31
1930
30 Aug
Round 16 Carlton16.12 (108) – 15.7 (97) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 11
1930
28 June
Round 9 St Kilda12.5 (77) – 13.14 (92) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 15
1920s · 18 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1929
7 Sept
Finals Week 1 Carlton12.9 (81) – 11.7 (73) St KildaMCGCarlton by 8
1929
29 June
Round 9 Carlton12.22 (94) – 7.15 (57) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 37
1928
4 Aug
Round 15 St Kilda13.15 (93) – 10.9 (69) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 24
1928
12 May
Round 4 Carlton16.24 (120) – 3.6 (24) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 96
1927
10 Sept
Round 18 Carlton15.16 (106) – 7.9 (51) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 55
1927
9 July
Round 11 St Kilda6.8 (44) – 21.9 (135) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 91
1926
10 July
Round 11 Carlton11.14 (80) – 9.9 (63) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 17
1925
11 July
Round 10 St Kilda8.17 (65) – 5.10 (40) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 25
1924
12 July
Round 12 Carlton14.15 (99) – 8.8 (56) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 43
1924
10 May
Round 3 St Kilda9.22 (76) – 13.12 (90) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 14
1923
21 July
Round 11 St Kilda7.14 (56) – 6.11 (47) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 9
1923
12 May
Round 2 Carlton8.8 (56) – 14.16 (100) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 44
1922
26 Aug
Round 15 St Kilda4.16 (40) – 5.19 (49) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 9
1922
10 June
Round 6 Carlton13.19 (97) – 12.14 (86) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 11
1921
23 July
Round 12 St Kilda5.14 (44) – 22.10 (142) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 98
1921
21 May
Round 3 Carlton15.11 (101) – 11.12 (78) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 23
1920
3 July
Round 10 St Kilda8.9 (57) – 11.15 (81) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 24
1920
1 May
Round 1 Carlton10.10 (70) – 5.11 (41) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 29
1910s · 16 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1919
23 Aug
Round 15 Carlton10.14 (74) – 9.4 (58) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 16
1919
9 June
Round 6 St Kilda7.11 (53) – 11.9 (75) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 22
1918
13 July
Round 10 St Kilda4.20 (44) – 2.5 (17) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 27
1918
25 May
Round 3 Carlton11.11 (77) – 7.9 (51) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 26
1915
21 Aug
Round 18 Carlton14.16 (100) – 6.8 (44) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 56
1915
19 June
Round 9 St Kilda1.1 (7) – 5.15 (45) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 38
1914
27 June
Round 11 St Kilda7.8 (50) – 7.11 (53) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 3
1914
2 May
Round 2 Carlton4.11 (35) – 6.12 (48) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 13
1913
2 Aug
Round 15 St Kilda10.10 (70) – 11.3 (69) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 1
1913
31 May
Round 6 Carlton4.13 (37) – 3.6 (24) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 13
1912
3 Aug
Round 15 St Kilda6.15 (51) – 7.12 (54) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 3
1912
1 June
Round 6 Carlton12.15 (87) – 6.11 (47) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 40
1911
29 July
Round 15 Carlton18.21 (129) – 2.3 (15) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 114
1911
3 June
Round 6 St Kilda5.12 (42) – 6.16 (52) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 10
1910
3 Sept
Round 18 St Kilda5.6 (36) – 2.12 (24) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 12
1910
25 June
Round 9 Carlton9.10 (64) – 4.7 (31) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 33
1900s · 25 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1909
28 Aug
Round 17 Carlton11.13 (79) – 5.3 (33) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 46
1909
12 June
Round 8 St Kilda5.10 (40) – 10.9 (69) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 29
1908
19 Sept
Semi-Finals Carlton12.12 (84) – 3.8 (26) St KildaMCGCarlton by 58
1908
27 June
Round 10 St Kilda6.5 (41) – 10.12 (72) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 31
1908
2 May
Round 1 Carlton6.12 (48) – 3.4 (22) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 26
1907
14 Sept
Semi-Finals Carlton13.13 (91) – 4.11 (35) St KildaMCGCarlton by 56
1907
22 June
Round 8 St Kilda3.15 (33) – 8.14 (62) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 29
1907
27 Apr
Round 1 Carlton4.6 (30) – 8.8 (56) St KildaPrinces ParkSt Kilda by 26
1906
7 July
Round 9 Carlton6.13 (49) – 3.7 (25) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 24
1906
12 May
Round 2 St Kilda5.5 (35) – 15.10 (100) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 65
1905
19 Aug
Round 14 Carlton9.19 (73) – 3.5 (23) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 50
1905
17 June
Round 7 St Kilda3.7 (25) – 8.15 (63) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 38
1904
3 Sept
Round 17 Carlton16.11 (107) – 7.7 (49) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 58
1904
16 July
Round 11 Carlton9.7 (61) – 4.1 (25) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 36
1904
28 May
Round 4 St Kilda4.7 (31) – 6.4 (40) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 9
1903
29 Aug
Round 17 St Kilda3.10 (28) – 4.7 (31) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 3
1903
11 July
Round 11 St Kilda4.3 (27) – 8.14 (62) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 35
1903
23 May
Round 4 Carlton12.16 (88) – 1.4 (10) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 78
1902
23 Aug
Round 16 Carlton6.11 (47) – 3.6 (24) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 23
1902
5 July
Round 10 Carlton10.12 (72) – 7.7 (49) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 23
1902
17 May
Round 3 St Kilda2.13 (25) – 4.9 (33) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 8
1901
13 July
Round 12 St Kilda7.8 (50) – 4.8 (32) CarltonJunction OvalSt Kilda by 18
1901
25 May
Round 5 Carlton5.10 (40) – 2.8 (20) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 20
1900
14 July
Round 11 Carlton7.7 (49) – 4.4 (28) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 21
1900
24 May
Round 4 St Kilda2.6 (18) – 3.9 (27) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 9
1890s · 6 games
YearRoundHomeScoreAwayVenueResult
1899
5 Aug
Round 13 Carlton6.11 (47) – 1.2 (8) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 39
1899
10 June
Round 6 St Kilda4.5 (29) – 4.7 (31) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 2
1898
20 Aug
Round 14 St Kilda8.7 (55) – 10.9 (69) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 14
1898
18 June
Round 7 Carlton5.13 (43) – 5.3 (33) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 10
1897
31 July
Round 13 Carlton8.11 (59) – 3.7 (25) St KildaPrinces ParkCarlton by 34
1897
19 June
Round 6 St Kilda3.6 (24) – 5.5 (35) CarltonJunction OvalCarlton by 11

Includes every completed VFL/AFL game between the two clubs, home-and-away and finals.