Carlton lead Melbourne 123–98 with 2 draws in 223 games since 1897. Their last meeting, in the 2026 Wildcard Finals at the MCG, went to Carlton by 19 points. They next meet in the 2027 Round 4, Sat 10 Apr 2027, 1:35pm AEST.
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 29 Aug | Wildcard Finals | Melbourne | 7.13 (55) – 10.14 (74) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 19 |
| 2026 29 Mar | Round 3 | Carlton | 11.11 (77) – 15.10 (100) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 23 |
| 2025 19 July | Round 19 | Carlton | 12.6 (78) – 10.10 (70) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 8 |
| 2024 9 May | Round 9 | Carlton | 12.5 (77) – 11.10 (76) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 1 |
| 2023 15 Sept | Semi-Finals | Melbourne | 9.17 (71) – 11.7 (73) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 2 |
| 2023 12 Aug | Round 22 | Carlton | 9.6 (60) – 8.8 (56) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 4 |
| 2023 2 June | Round 12 | Melbourne | 8.13 (61) – 6.8 (44) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 17 |
| 2022 13 Aug | Round 22 | Melbourne | 11.13 (79) – 10.14 (74) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 5 |
| 2021 16 May | Round 9 | Melbourne | 13.16 (94) – 10.8 (68) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 26 |
| 2020 13 June | Round 2 | Carlton | 7.11 (53) – 8.6 (54) | Melbourne | Marvel Stadium | Melbourne by 1 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 29 Aug | Wildcard Finals | Melbourne | 7.13 (55) – 10.14 (74) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 19 |
| 2023 15 Sept | Semi-Finals | Melbourne | 9.17 (71) – 11.7 (73) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 2 |
| 2000 13 Aug | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 12.15 (87) – 15.6 (96) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 9 |
| 1994 11 Sept | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 14.12 (96) – 18.15 (123) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 27 |
| 1988 17 Sept | Preliminary Finals | Carlton | 14.14 (98) – 19.6 (120) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Melbourne by 22 |
| 1962 1 Sept | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 11.12 (78) – 11.10 (76) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 2 |
| 1959 12 Sept | Semi-Finals | Melbourne | 11.15 (81) – 4.13 (37) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 44 |
| 1941 13 Sept | Semi-Finals | Melbourne | 16.13 (109) – 11.16 (82) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 27 |
| 1936 12 Sept | Finals Week 1 | Melbourne | 14.13 (97) – 11.22 (88) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 9 |
| 1915 28 Aug | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 11.12 (78) – 10.7 (67) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 11 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 29 Aug | Wildcard Finals | Melbourne | 7.13 (55) – 10.14 (74) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 19 |
| 2026 29 Mar | Round 3 | Carlton | 11.11 (77) – 15.10 (100) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 23 |
| 2025 19 July | Round 19 | Carlton | 12.6 (78) – 10.10 (70) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 8 |
| 2024 9 May | Round 9 | Carlton | 12.5 (77) – 11.10 (76) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 1 |
| 2023 15 Sept | Semi-Finals | Melbourne | 9.17 (71) – 11.7 (73) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 2 |
| 2023 12 Aug | Round 22 | Carlton | 9.6 (60) – 8.8 (56) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 4 |
| 2023 2 June | Round 12 | Melbourne | 8.13 (61) – 6.8 (44) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 17 |
| 2022 13 Aug | Round 22 | Melbourne | 11.13 (79) – 10.14 (74) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 5 |
| 2021 16 May | Round 9 | Melbourne | 13.16 (94) – 10.8 (68) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 26 |
| 2020 13 June | Round 2 | Carlton | 7.11 (53) – 8.6 (54) | Melbourne | Marvel Stadium | Melbourne by 1 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 7 July | Round 16 | Carlton | 15.10 (100) – 15.15 (105) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 5 |
| 2018 20 May | Round 9 | Carlton | 7.8 (50) – 25.9 (159) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 109 |
| 2017 9 July | Round 16 | Carlton | 12.10 (82) – 14.6 (90) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 8 |
| 2017 2 Apr | Round 2 | Melbourne | 13.8 (86) – 9.10 (64) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 22 |
| 2016 21 Aug | Round 22 | Carlton | 11.12 (78) – 7.16 (58) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 20 |
| 2015 23 Aug | Round 21 | Carlton | 12.6 (78) – 7.13 (55) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 23 |
| 2014 12 Apr | Round 4 | Carlton | 7.16 (58) – 12.9 (81) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 23 |
| 2013 5 May | Round 6 | Carlton | 18.13 (121) – 8.12 (60) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 61 |
| 2012 27 May | Round 9 | Carlton | 15.17 (107) – 6.13 (49) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 58 |
| 2011 6 Aug | Round 20 | Carlton | 21.8 (134) – 7.16 (58) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 76 |
| 2011 27 May | Round 10 | Melbourne | 6.10 (46) – 13.15 (93) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 47 |
| 2010 5 June | Round 11 | Carlton | 15.11 (101) – 9.6 (60) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 41 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 22 Aug | Round 21 | Carlton | 24.9 (153) – 15.6 (96) | Melbourne | Marvel Stadium | Carlton by 57 |
| 2008 20 Apr | Round 5 | Melbourne | 9.14 (68) – 15.11 (101) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 33 |
| 2007 2 Sept | Round 22 | Melbourne | 21.13 (139) – 15.18 (108) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 31 |
| 2007 8 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 14.17 (101) – 19.10 (124) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 23 |
| 2006 5 Aug | Round 18 | Carlton | 12.8 (80) – 10.13 (73) | Melbourne | Marvel Stadium | Carlton by 7 |
| 2006 2 Apr | Round 1 | Melbourne | 10.12 (72) – 13.15 (93) | Carlton | Marvel Stadium | Carlton by 21 |
| 2005 21 May | Round 9 | Carlton | 13.14 (92) – 15.20 (110) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 18 |
| 2004 21 Aug | Round 21 | Carlton | 14.9 (93) – 8.14 (62) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 31 |
| 2004 2 May | Round 6 | Melbourne | 25.10 (160) – 8.7 (55) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 105 |
| 2003 6 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 14.6 (90) – 14.13 (97) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 7 |
| 2002 14 July | Round 15 | Carlton | 14.11 (95) – 21.13 (139) | Melbourne | Marvel Stadium | Melbourne by 44 |
| 2001 14 July | Round 15 | Carlton | 16.15 (111) – 18.9 (117) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 6 |
| 2000 13 Aug | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 12.15 (87) – 15.6 (96) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 9 |
| 2000 3 June | Round 13 | Melbourne | 9.7 (61) – 25.9 (159) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 98 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1999 22 May | Round 9 | Carlton | 15.7 (97) – 9.10 (64) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 33 |
| 1998 8 Aug | Round 19 | Melbourne | 16.17 (113) – 8.16 (64) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 49 |
| 1998 19 Apr | Round 4 | Carlton | 10.10 (70) – 10.12 (72) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 2 |
| 1997 12 July | Round 15 | Melbourne | 18.11 (119) – 15.10 (100) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 19 |
| 1996 10 Aug | Round 19 | Melbourne | 20.9 (129) – 17.8 (110) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 19 |
| 1996 20 Apr | Round 4 | Carlton | 21.7 (133) – 12.14 (86) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 47 |
| 1995 12 June | Round 11 | Melbourne | 12.8 (80) – 16.16 (112) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 32 |
| 1994 11 Sept | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 14.12 (96) – 18.15 (123) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 27 |
| 1994 11 June | Round 12 | Melbourne | 13.16 (94) – 18.13 (121) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 27 |
| 1993 29 May | Round 10 | Carlton | 17.26 (128) – 11.8 (74) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 54 |
| 1992 30 May | Round 11 | Melbourne | 10.5 (65) – 14.15 (99) | Carlton | Waverley Park | Carlton by 34 |
| 1991 27 July | Round 19 | Carlton | 10.8 (68) – 11.14 (80) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 12 |
| 1991 13 Apr | Round 4 | Melbourne | 23.17 (155) – 17.8 (110) | Carlton | Waverley Park | Melbourne by 45 |
| 1990 11 June | Round 11 | Melbourne | 15.9 (99) – 13.15 (93) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 6 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1989 29 July | Round 17 | Carlton | 15.16 (106) – 10.19 (79) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 27 |
| 1989 13 May | Round 7 | Melbourne | 12.14 (86) – 11.14 (80) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 6 |
| 1988 17 Sept | Preliminary Finals | Carlton | 14.14 (98) – 19.6 (120) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Melbourne by 22 |
| 1988 27 Aug | Round 22 | Melbourne | 14.12 (96) – 10.6 (66) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 30 |
| 1988 25 June | Round 13 | Melbourne | 10.6 (66) – 5.13 (43) | Carlton | Waverley Park | Melbourne by 23 |
| 1987 8 June | Round 11 | Melbourne | 13.12 (90) – 21.9 (135) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 45 |
| 1986 30 Aug | Round 22 | Carlton | 20.19 (139) – 6.17 (53) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 86 |
| 1986 31 May | Round 10 | Melbourne | 6.13 (49) – 25.15 (165) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 116 |
| 1985 20 July | Round 16 | Carlton | 14.15 (99) – 5.9 (39) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Carlton by 60 |
| 1985 25 Apr | Round 5 | Melbourne | 18.13 (121) – 13.14 (92) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 29 |
| 1984 28 July | Round 17 | Carlton | 7.10 (52) – 3.8 (26) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 26 |
| 1984 12 May | Round 7 | Melbourne | 16.9 (105) – 18.14 (122) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 17 |
| 1983 2 July | Round 15 | Carlton | 9.13 (67) – 15.16 (106) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 39 |
| 1983 16 Apr | Round 4 | Melbourne | 13.12 (90) – 14.15 (99) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 9 |
| 1982 3 July | Round 15 | Carlton | 18.20 (128) – 16.15 (111) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 17 |
| 1982 24 Apr | Round 5 | Melbourne | 9.12 (66) – 9.22 (76) | Carlton | Waverley Park | Carlton by 10 |
| 1981 25 July | Round 17 | Carlton | 23.15 (153) – 15.10 (100) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 53 |
| 1981 9 May | Round 7 | Melbourne | 8.8 (56) – 12.24 (96) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 40 |
| 1980 12 July | Round 15 | Melbourne | 15.13 (103) – 18.24 (132) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 29 |
| 1980 25 Apr | Round 5 | Carlton | 14.19 (103) – 9.20 (74) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Carlton by 29 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1979 21 July | Round 16 | Melbourne | 9.7 (61) – 19.26 (140) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 79 |
| 1979 5 May | Round 5 | Carlton | 15.20 (110) – 13.18 (96) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 14 |
| 1978 15 July | Round 15 | Melbourne | 2.14 (26) – 17.13 (115) | Carlton | Waverley Park | Carlton by 89 |
| 1978 15 Apr | Round 3 | Carlton | 13.20 (98) – 11.19 (85) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 13 |
| 1977 30 July | Round 18 | Carlton | 17.11 (113) – 7.4 (46) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Carlton by 67 |
| 1977 14 May | Round 7 | Melbourne | 14.12 (96) – 16.20 (116) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 20 |
| 1976 3 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 18.7 (115) – 6.22 (58) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Carlton by 57 |
| 1976 24 Apr | Round 4 | Melbourne | 17.12 (114) – 24.13 (157) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 43 |
| 1975 9 Aug | Round 19 | Melbourne | 11.23 (89) – 7.9 (51) | Carlton | Waverley Park | Melbourne by 38 |
| 1975 24 May | Round 8 | Carlton | 16.14 (110) – 11.15 (81) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 29 |
| 1974 22 June | Round 12 | Melbourne | 11.13 (79) – 15.18 (108) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 29 |
| 1974 6 Apr | Round 1 | Carlton | 14.13 (97) – 6.12 (48) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 49 |
| 1973 14 July | Round 15 | Carlton | 18.14 (122) – 12.9 (81) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 41 |
| 1973 23 Apr | Round 3 | Melbourne | 11.9 (75) – 11.16 (82) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 7 |
| 1972 5 Aug | Round 18 | Melbourne | 8.18 (66) – 11.11 (77) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 11 |
| 1972 13 May | Round 7 | Carlton | 10.15 (75) – 5.8 (38) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Carlton by 37 |
| 1971 3 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 12.16 (88) – 11.6 (72) | Melbourne | Waverley Park | Carlton by 16 |
| 1971 17 Apr | Round 3 | Melbourne | 19.13 (127) – 15.10 (100) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 27 |
| 1970 29 Aug | Round 22 | Melbourne | 12.15 (87) – 14.17 (101) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 14 |
| 1970 15 June | Round 11 | Carlton | 22.15 (147) – 9.8 (62) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 85 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1969 16 Aug | Round 18 | Melbourne | 14.15 (99) – 13.14 (92) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 7 |
| 1969 17 May | Round 7 | Carlton | 14.24 (108) – 12.6 (78) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 30 |
| 1968 29 June | Round 11 | Carlton | 11.19 (85) – 6.7 (43) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 42 |
| 1967 5 Aug | Round 15 | Carlton | 7.10 (52) – 6.13 (49) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 3 |
| 1967 6 May | Round 4 | Melbourne | 5.15 (45) – 16.8 (104) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 59 |
| 1966 13 Aug | Round 16 | Carlton | 14.15 (99) – 10.10 (70) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 29 |
| 1966 21 May | Round 5 | Melbourne | 3.14 (32) – 11.13 (79) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 47 |
| 1965 5 June | Round 8 | Carlton | 6.22 (58) – 13.17 (95) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 37 |
| 1964 25 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 9.14 (68) – 12.8 (80) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 12 |
| 1964 2 May | Round 3 | Melbourne | 11.13 (79) – 4.9 (33) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 46 |
| 1963 29 June | Round 10 | Carlton | 8.8 (56) – 12.12 (84) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 28 |
| 1962 1 Sept | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 11.12 (78) – 11.10 (76) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 2 |
| 1962 25 Aug | Round 18 | Melbourne | 11.9 (75) – 5.10 (40) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 35 |
| 1962 4 June | Round 7 | Carlton | 10.10 (70) – 7.12 (54) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 16 |
| 1961 26 Aug | Round 18 | Carlton | 13.12 (90) – 13.13 (91) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 1 |
| 1961 3 June | Round 7 | Melbourne | 15.14 (104) – 11.13 (79) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 25 |
| 1960 9 July | Round 11 | Melbourne | 9.17 (71) – 6.22 (58) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 13 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1959 12 Sept | Semi-Finals | Melbourne | 11.15 (81) – 4.13 (37) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 44 |
| 1959 15 Aug | Round 16 | Melbourne | 13.14 (92) – 7.5 (47) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 45 |
| 1959 23 May | Round 5 | Carlton | 10.13 (73) – 9.7 (61) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 12 |
| 1958 28 June | Round 12 | Carlton | 9.14 (68) – 12.12 (84) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 16 |
| 1958 12 Apr | Round 1 | Melbourne | 11.13 (79) – 9.11 (65) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 14 |
| 1957 8 June | Round 8 | Carlton | 10.11 (71) – 14.15 (99) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 28 |
| 1956 14 July | Round 13 | Melbourne | 14.10 (94) – 12.7 (79) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 15 |
| 1956 21 Apr | Round 2 | Carlton | 6.11 (47) – 12.18 (90) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 43 |
| 1955 4 June | Round 8 | Melbourne | 20.15 (135) – 9.16 (70) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 65 |
| 1954 17 July | Round 13 | Melbourne | 10.16 (76) – 6.5 (41) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 35 |
| 1954 24 Apr | Round 2 | Carlton | 12.10 (82) – 15.11 (101) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 19 |
| 1953 25 July | Round 13 | Carlton | 12.24 (96) – 10.10 (70) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 26 |
| 1953 2 May | Round 2 | Melbourne | 8.11 (59) – 13.12 (90) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 31 |
| 1952 12 July | Round 12 | Carlton | 6.14 (50) – 6.14 (50) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Draw |
| 1951 25 Aug | Round 17 | Carlton | 15.16 (106) – 8.13 (61) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 45 |
| 1951 2 June | Round 6 | Melbourne | 11.12 (78) – 8.10 (58) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 20 |
| 1950 8 July | Round 12 | Carlton | 8.15 (63) – 10.14 (74) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 11 |
| 1950 22 Apr | Round 1 | Melbourne | 13.13 (91) – 10.11 (71) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 20 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1949 18 June | Round 10 | Carlton | 11.12 (78) – 12.14 (86) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 8 |
| 1948 28 Aug | Round 18 | Carlton | 13.14 (92) – 15.11 (101) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 9 |
| 1948 29 May | Round 7 | Melbourne | 15.12 (102) – 7.9 (51) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 51 |
| 1947 5 July | Round 12 | Melbourne | 9.10 (64) – 10.9 (69) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 5 |
| 1947 19 Apr | Round 1 | Carlton | 17.20 (122) – 16.13 (109) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 13 |
| 1946 20 July | Round 13 | Melbourne | 10.12 (72) – 7.13 (55) | Carlton | Punt Rd | Melbourne by 17 |
| 1946 27 Apr | Round 2 | Carlton | 9.12 (66) – 10.12 (72) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 6 |
| 1945 7 July | Round 12 | Melbourne | 12.8 (80) – 12.9 (81) | Carlton | Punt Rd | Carlton by 1 |
| 1945 21 Apr | Round 1 | Carlton | 13.9 (87) – 15.18 (108) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 21 |
| 1944 5 Aug | Round 14 | Carlton | 4.14 (38) – 8.6 (54) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 16 |
| 1944 20 May | Round 3 | Melbourne | 12.5 (77) – 14.8 (92) | Carlton | Punt Rd | Carlton by 15 |
| 1943 19 June | Round 7 | Melbourne | 13.14 (92) – 11.21 (87) | Carlton | Punt Rd | Melbourne by 5 |
| 1942 11 July | Round 10 | Carlton | 13.17 (95) – 10.7 (67) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 28 |
| 1941 13 Sept | Semi-Finals | Melbourne | 16.13 (109) – 11.16 (82) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 27 |
| 1941 30 Aug | Round 18 | Carlton | 16.17 (113) – 11.22 (88) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 25 |
| 1941 16 June | Round 7 | Melbourne | 14.13 (97) – 19.10 (124) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 27 |
| 1940 10 Aug | Round 15 | Melbourne | 14.12 (96) – 20.13 (133) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 37 |
| 1940 18 May | Round 4 | Carlton | 13.12 (90) – 16.20 (116) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 26 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 17 June | Round 9 | Carlton | 19.19 (133) – 15.13 (103) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 30 |
| 1938 20 Aug | Round 17 | Melbourne | 14.12 (96) – 11.13 (79) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 17 |
| 1938 28 May | Round 6 | Carlton | 14.18 (102) – 16.11 (107) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 5 |
| 1937 24 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 16.24 (120) – 16.8 (104) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 16 |
| 1937 8 May | Round 3 | Melbourne | 15.17 (107) – 10.11 (71) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 36 |
| 1936 12 Sept | Finals Week 1 | Melbourne | 14.13 (97) – 11.22 (88) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 9 |
| 1936 27 June | Round 9 | Carlton | 9.14 (68) – 11.17 (83) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 15 |
| 1935 15 June | Round 8 | Melbourne | 7.12 (54) – 9.12 (66) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 12 |
| 1934 30 June | Round 8 | Carlton | 19.20 (134) – 11.19 (85) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 49 |
| 1933 26 Aug | Round 17 | Melbourne | 10.11 (71) – 19.21 (135) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 64 |
| 1933 5 June | Round 6 | Carlton | 13.13 (91) – 12.15 (87) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 4 |
| 1932 27 Aug | Round 17 | Carlton | 15.15 (105) – 9.9 (63) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 42 |
| 1932 4 June | Round 6 | Melbourne | 9.9 (63) – 12.15 (87) | Carlton | Olympic Park | Carlton by 24 |
| 1931 20 June | Round 8 | Carlton | 18.14 (122) – 9.4 (58) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 64 |
| 1930 23 Aug | Round 15 | Melbourne | 12.11 (83) – 11.11 (77) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 6 |
| 1930 21 June | Round 8 | Carlton | 9.16 (70) – 9.18 (72) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 2 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1929 22 June | Round 8 | Melbourne | 5.12 (42) – 10.17 (77) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 35 |
| 1928 4 June | Round 8 | Melbourne | 10.14 (74) – 9.10 (64) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 10 |
| 1927 2 July | Round 10 | Carlton | 8.7 (55) – 10.10 (70) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 15 |
| 1926 7 Aug | Round 13 | Melbourne | 12.18 (90) – 8.10 (58) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 32 |
| 1926 8 May | Round 2 | Carlton | 9.15 (69) – 8.10 (58) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 11 |
| 1925 22 Aug | Round 14 | Carlton | 6.9 (45) – 18.14 (122) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 77 |
| 1925 16 May | Round 3 | Melbourne | 12.12 (84) – 4.14 (38) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 46 |
| 1924 19 July | Round 13 | Melbourne | 7.13 (55) – 9.8 (62) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 7 |
| 1924 17 May | Round 4 | Carlton | 11.10 (76) – 14.25 (109) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 33 |
| 1923 8 Sept | Round 17 | Carlton | 9.20 (74) – 7.4 (46) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 28 |
| 1923 23 June | Round 8 | Melbourne | 9.11 (65) – 11.8 (74) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 9 |
| 1922 5 Aug | Round 13 | Melbourne | 10.4 (64) – 8.13 (61) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 3 |
| 1922 27 May | Round 4 | Carlton | 14.12 (96) – 8.16 (64) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 32 |
| 1921 10 Sept | Round 17 | Carlton | 14.16 (100) – 10.16 (76) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 24 |
| 1921 25 June | Round 8 | Melbourne | 7.13 (55) – 8.14 (62) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 7 |
| 1920 14 Aug | Round 15 | Melbourne | 3.7 (25) – 12.15 (87) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 62 |
| 1920 5 June | Round 6 | Carlton | 7.24 (66) – 13.6 (84) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 18 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1919 16 Aug | Round 14 | Melbourne | 5.6 (36) – 13.18 (96) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 60 |
| 1919 31 May | Round 5 | Carlton | 18.15 (123) – 5.4 (34) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 89 |
| 1915 28 Aug | Finals Week 1 | Carlton | 11.12 (78) – 10.7 (67) | Melbourne | MCG | Carlton by 11 |
| 1915 24 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 11.8 (74) – 5.15 (45) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 29 |
| 1915 22 May | Round 5 | Melbourne | 8.3 (51) – 10.12 (72) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 21 |
| 1914 25 July | Round 15 | Melbourne | 8.10 (58) – 16.15 (111) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 53 |
| 1914 30 May | Round 6 | Carlton | 13.19 (97) – 5.9 (39) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 58 |
| 1913 5 July | Round 12 | Melbourne | 10.7 (67) – 7.12 (54) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 13 |
| 1913 10 May | Round 3 | Carlton | 11.13 (79) – 7.11 (53) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 26 |
| 1912 27 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 4.18 (42) – 5.7 (37) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 5 |
| 1912 25 May | Round 5 | Melbourne | 8.2 (50) – 5.14 (44) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 6 |
| 1911 2 Sept | Round 18 | Carlton | 9.8 (62) – 8.6 (54) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 8 |
| 1911 17 June | Round 9 | Melbourne | 9.2 (56) – 13.11 (89) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 33 |
| 1910 16 July | Round 12 | Carlton | 13.22 (100) – 4.11 (35) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 65 |
| 1910 21 May | Round 3 | Melbourne | 5.6 (36) – 9.15 (69) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 33 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1909 31 July | Round 14 | Carlton | 10.21 (81) – 4.6 (30) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 51 |
| 1909 29 May | Round 5 | Melbourne | 8.9 (57) – 12.8 (80) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 23 |
| 1908 4 July | Round 11 | Carlton | 8.15 (63) – 4.7 (31) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 32 |
| 1908 9 May | Round 2 | Melbourne | 6.8 (44) – 9.8 (62) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 18 |
| 1907 31 Aug | Round 17 | Carlton | 9.8 (62) – 4.12 (36) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 26 |
| 1907 6 July | Round 10 | Carlton | 9.16 (70) – 8.6 (54) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 16 |
| 1907 11 May | Round 3 | Melbourne | 7.5 (47) – 12.14 (86) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 39 |
| 1906 30 June | Round 8 | Melbourne | 3.7 (25) – 9.16 (70) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 45 |
| 1906 5 May | Round 1 | Carlton | 12.11 (83) – 8.8 (56) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 27 |
| 1905 9 Sept | Round 17 | Melbourne | 5.8 (38) – 18.17 (125) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 87 |
| 1905 5 Aug | Round 13 | Carlton | 12.10 (82) – 2.8 (20) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 62 |
| 1905 10 June | Round 6 | Melbourne | 5.8 (38) – 6.5 (41) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 3 |
| 1904 27 Aug | Round 16 | Carlton | 1.8 (14) – 5.13 (43) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 29 |
| 1904 30 July | Round 13 | Carlton | 6.14 (50) – 4.10 (34) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 16 |
| 1904 6 June | Round 6 | Melbourne | 8.10 (58) – 5.5 (35) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 23 |
| 1903 15 Aug | Round 15 | Melbourne | 5.2 (32) – 9.13 (67) | Carlton | MCG | Carlton by 35 |
| 1903 8 Aug | Round 14 | Carlton | 5.11 (41) – 8.8 (56) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 15 |
| 1903 8 June | Round 7 | Melbourne | 4.8 (32) – 1.2 (8) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 24 |
| 1902 16 Aug | Round 15 | Melbourne | 7.5 (47) – 1.7 (13) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 34 |
| 1902 12 July | Round 11 | Melbourne | 4.12 (36) – 4.9 (33) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 3 |
| 1902 24 May | Round 4 | Carlton | 6.13 (49) – 8.12 (60) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 11 |
| 1901 20 July | Round 13 | Carlton | 5.6 (36) – 6.6 (42) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 6 |
| 1901 1 June | Round 6 | Melbourne | 7.7 (49) – 5.4 (34) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 15 |
| 1900 18 Aug | Round 3 | Carlton | 6.6 (42) – 3.4 (22) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 20 |
| 1900 7 July | Round 10 | Melbourne | 9.14 (68) – 5.3 (33) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 35 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1899 9 Sept | Round 17 | Carlton | 6.5 (41) – 2.4 (16) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Carlton by 25 |
| 1899 15 July | Round 10 | Melbourne | 7.12 (54) – 3.4 (22) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 32 |
| 1899 24 May | Round 3 | Carlton | 3.1 (19) – 6.9 (45) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Melbourne by 26 |
| 1898 9 July | Round 9 | Carlton | 4.4 (28) – 3.10 (28) | Melbourne | Princes Park | Draw |
| 1898 21 May | Round 2 | Melbourne | 12.11 (83) – 4.2 (26) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 57 |
| 1897 24 July | Round 12 | Carlton | 2.6 (18) – 5.16 (46) | Melbourne | MCG | Melbourne by 28 |
| 1897 5 June | Round 5 | Melbourne | 15.17 (107) – 3.8 (26) | Carlton | MCG | Melbourne by 81 |
Includes every completed VFL/AFL game between the two clubs, home-and-away and finals.