Hawthorn lead St Kilda 86–78 with 2 draws in 166 games since 1925. They have met once in a Grand Final; Hawthorn won the most recent, in 1971. Their last meeting, in the 2026 Round 12 at Marvel Stadium, went to Hawthorn by 52 points. They next meet in the 2027 Round 11, Sat 29 May 2027, 1:15pm AEST.
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 28 May | Round 12 | St Kilda | 9.13 (67) – 18.11 (119) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 52 |
| 2025 5 July | Round 17 | St Kilda | 10.14 (74) – 14.10 (94) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 20 |
| 2024 11 May | Round 9 | Hawthorn | 8.10 (58) – 7.11 (53) | St Kilda | York Park | Hawthorn by 5 |
| 2023 30 July | Round 20 | Hawthorn | 14.9 (93) – 19.8 (122) | St Kilda | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 29 |
| 2023 27 May | Round 11 | St Kilda | 12.6 (78) – 12.16 (88) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 10 |
| 2022 30 July | Round 20 | St Kilda | 10.15 (75) – 9.9 (63) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 12 |
| 2022 10 Apr | Round 4 | Hawthorn | 10.13 (73) – 22.10 (142) | St Kilda | MCG | St Kilda by 69 |
| 2021 1 May | Round 7 | St Kilda | 19.14 (128) – 9.5 (59) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 69 |
| 2020 6 Sept | Round 16 | St Kilda | 11.14 (80) – 9.12 (66) | Hawthorn | People First Stadium | St Kilda by 14 |
| 2019 14 Apr | Round 4 | St Kilda | 10.14 (74) – 10.9 (69) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 5 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 20 Sept | Preliminary Finals | Hawthorn | 18.10 (118) – 9.10 (64) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 54 |
| 1971 25 Sept | Grand Final | Hawthorn | 12.10 (82) – 11.9 (75) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 7 |
| 1971 11 Sept | Semi-Finals | Hawthorn | 12.18 (90) – 12.16 (88) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 2 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 28 May | Round 12 | St Kilda | 9.13 (67) – 18.11 (119) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 52 |
| 2025 5 July | Round 17 | St Kilda | 10.14 (74) – 14.10 (94) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 20 |
| 2024 11 May | Round 9 | Hawthorn | 8.10 (58) – 7.11 (53) | St Kilda | York Park | Hawthorn by 5 |
| 2023 30 July | Round 20 | Hawthorn | 14.9 (93) – 19.8 (122) | St Kilda | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 29 |
| 2023 27 May | Round 11 | St Kilda | 12.6 (78) – 12.16 (88) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 10 |
| 2022 30 July | Round 20 | St Kilda | 10.15 (75) – 9.9 (63) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 12 |
| 2022 10 Apr | Round 4 | Hawthorn | 10.13 (73) – 22.10 (142) | St Kilda | MCG | St Kilda by 69 |
| 2021 1 May | Round 7 | St Kilda | 19.14 (128) – 9.5 (59) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 69 |
| 2020 6 Sept | Round 16 | St Kilda | 11.14 (80) – 9.12 (66) | Hawthorn | People First Stadium | St Kilda by 14 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 14 Apr | Round 4 | St Kilda | 10.14 (74) – 10.9 (69) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 5 |
| 2018 18 Aug | Round 22 | St Kilda | 11.10 (76) – 12.8 (80) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 4 |
| 2018 28 Apr | Round 6 | Hawthorn | 13.11 (89) – 7.12 (54) | St Kilda | University of Tasmania Stadium | Hawthorn by 35 |
| 2017 29 Apr | Round 6 | Hawthorn | 8.7 (55) – 19.16 (130) | St Kilda | University of Tasmania Stadium | St Kilda by 75 |
| 2016 16 Apr | Round 4 | Hawthorn | 13.9 (87) – 13.6 (84) | St Kilda | York Park | Hawthorn by 3 |
| 2015 7 June | Round 10 | St Kilda | 10.9 (69) – 20.12 (132) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 63 |
| 2014 3 May | Round 7 | Hawthorn | 27.13 (175) – 4.6 (30) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 145 |
| 2013 9 Aug | Round 20 | St Kilda | 7.14 (56) – 14.18 (102) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 46 |
| 2012 5 May | Round 6 | St Kilda | 13.10 (88) – 18.15 (123) | Hawthorn | MCG | Hawthorn by 35 |
| 2011 15 May | Round 8 | Hawthorn | 14.15 (99) – 10.9 (69) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 30 |
| 2010 23 July | Round 17 | St Kilda | 14.3 (87) – 13.9 (87) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Draw |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 8 Aug | Round 19 | Hawthorn | 7.7 (49) – 10.14 (74) | St Kilda | York Park | St Kilda by 25 |
| 2008 20 Sept | Preliminary Finals | Hawthorn | 18.10 (118) – 9.10 (64) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 54 |
| 2008 19 July | Round 16 | St Kilda | 18.11 (119) – 13.11 (89) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 30 |
| 2007 21 July | Round 16 | St Kilda | 14.11 (95) – 11.12 (78) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 17 |
| 2007 19 May | Round 8 | Hawthorn | 10.12 (72) – 6.8 (44) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 28 |
| 2006 1 July | Round 13 | St Kilda | 18.17 (125) – 8.7 (55) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 70 |
| 2005 11 June | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 8.6 (54) – 15.10 (100) | St Kilda | MCG | St Kilda by 46 |
| 2004 18 June | Round 13 | St Kilda | 19.13 (127) – 9.7 (61) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | St Kilda by 66 |
| 2003 1 June | Round 10 | St Kilda | 17.16 (118) – 14.6 (90) | Hawthorn | MCG | St Kilda by 28 |
| 2002 30 June | Round 13 | St Kilda | 11.12 (78) – 13.9 (87) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 9 |
| 2001 1 Sept | Round 22 | Hawthorn | 13.9 (87) – 13.11 (89) | St Kilda | MCG | St Kilda by 2 |
| 2001 12 May | Round 7 | St Kilda | 15.9 (99) – 16.14 (110) | Hawthorn | Marvel Stadium | Hawthorn by 11 |
| 2000 11 June | Round 14 | St Kilda | 13.8 (86) – 27.9 (171) | Hawthorn | MCG | Hawthorn by 85 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1999 19 June | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 17.7 (109) – 14.12 (96) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 13 |
| 1998 8 Aug | Round 19 | St Kilda | 10.9 (69) – 19.14 (128) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 59 |
| 1998 18 Apr | Round 4 | Hawthorn | 18.13 (121) – 20.9 (129) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | St Kilda by 8 |
| 1997 19 July | Round 16 | Hawthorn | 9.8 (62) – 20.21 (141) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | St Kilda by 79 |
| 1997 29 Mar | Round 1 | St Kilda | 10.11 (71) – 11.11 (77) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 6 |
| 1996 24 Aug | Round 21 | St Kilda | 9.9 (63) – 12.8 (80) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 17 |
| 1996 4 May | Round 6 | Hawthorn | 9.11 (65) – 13.8 (86) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | St Kilda by 21 |
| 1995 12 Aug | Round 19 | Hawthorn | 14.13 (97) – 16.9 (105) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | St Kilda by 8 |
| 1995 22 Apr | Round 4 | St Kilda | 10.10 (70) – 16.10 (106) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 36 |
| 1994 9 July | Round 16 | Hawthorn | 21.16 (142) – 11.12 (78) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 64 |
| 1994 26 Mar | Round 1 | St Kilda | 15.7 (97) – 23.15 (153) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 56 |
| 1993 19 June | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 23.14 (152) – 11.8 (74) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 78 |
| 1992 25 July | Round 19 | Hawthorn | 7.13 (55) – 19.16 (130) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | St Kilda by 75 |
| 1992 11 Apr | Round 4 | St Kilda | 16.12 (108) – 14.14 (98) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 10 |
| 1991 1 June | Round 11 | Hawthorn | 10.17 (77) – 15.13 (103) | St Kilda | Princes Park | St Kilda by 26 |
| 1990 11 Aug | Round 19 | Hawthorn | 17.17 (119) – 13.5 (83) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 36 |
| 1990 5 May | Round 6 | St Kilda | 15.14 (104) – 14.17 (101) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 3 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1989 2 Sept | Round 22 | Hawthorn | 28.13 (181) – 13.13 (91) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 90 |
| 1989 17 June | Round 12 | St Kilda | 8.6 (54) – 10.12 (72) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 18 |
| 1988 20 Aug | Round 21 | Hawthorn | 18.15 (123) – 11.12 (78) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 45 |
| 1988 4 June | Round 10 | St Kilda | 17.19 (121) – 21.11 (137) | Hawthorn | MCG | Hawthorn by 16 |
| 1987 30 May | Round 10 | Hawthorn | 23.16 (154) – 15.8 (98) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 56 |
| 1986 5 July | Round 15 | Hawthorn | 8.11 (59) – 5.8 (38) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 21 |
| 1986 19 Apr | Round 4 | St Kilda | 17.14 (116) – 19.14 (128) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 12 |
| 1985 3 Aug | Round 18 | St Kilda | 13.16 (94) – 20.15 (135) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 41 |
| 1985 11 May | Round 7 | Hawthorn | 28.15 (183) – 8.9 (57) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 126 |
| 1984 30 June | Round 14 | St Kilda | 4.6 (30) – 19.20 (134) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 104 |
| 1984 23 Apr | Round 4 | Hawthorn | 23.21 (159) – 14.15 (99) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 60 |
| 1983 25 June | Round 14 | Hawthorn | 21.17 (143) – 9.20 (74) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 69 |
| 1983 9 Apr | Round 3 | St Kilda | 6.6 (42) – 26.15 (171) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 129 |
| 1982 28 Aug | Round 22 | Hawthorn | 23.23 (161) – 11.7 (73) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 88 |
| 1982 27 Mar | Round 1 | St Kilda | 12.16 (88) – 17.17 (119) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 31 |
| 1981 15 Aug | Round 20 | St Kilda | 9.14 (68) – 10.17 (77) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 9 |
| 1981 30 May | Round 10 | Hawthorn | 13.17 (95) – 11.14 (80) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 15 |
| 1980 21 June | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 21.17 (143) – 16.13 (109) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 34 |
| 1980 5 Apr | Round 2 | St Kilda | 11.17 (83) – 15.26 (116) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 33 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1979 23 June | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 19.18 (132) – 13.15 (93) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 39 |
| 1979 7 Apr | Round 1 | St Kilda | 19.14 (128) – 14.19 (103) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 25 |
| 1978 19 Aug | Round 20 | Hawthorn | 12.11 (83) – 21.13 (139) | St Kilda | Waverley Park | St Kilda by 56 |
| 1978 27 May | Round 9 | St Kilda | 8.9 (57) – 13.19 (97) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 40 |
| 1977 23 July | Round 17 | St Kilda | 11.11 (77) – 24.19 (163) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 86 |
| 1977 7 May | Round 6 | Hawthorn | 25.41 (191) – 16.7 (103) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 88 |
| 1976 19 June | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 13.19 (97) – 18.14 (122) | St Kilda | Princes Park | St Kilda by 25 |
| 1976 3 Apr | Round 1 | St Kilda | 13.11 (89) – 16.15 (111) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 22 |
| 1975 28 June | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 11.19 (85) – 7.19 (61) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 24 |
| 1975 12 Apr | Round 2 | St Kilda | 11.15 (81) – 17.19 (121) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 40 |
| 1974 17 Aug | Round 20 | St Kilda | 11.9 (75) – 16.12 (108) | Hawthorn | Waverley Park | Hawthorn by 33 |
| 1974 1 June | Round 9 | Hawthorn | 18.15 (123) – 10.16 (76) | St Kilda | Princes Park | Hawthorn by 47 |
| 1973 18 Aug | Round 20 | Hawthorn | 11.11 (77) – 15.8 (98) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 21 |
| 1973 4 June | Round 9 | St Kilda | 11.12 (78) – 8.16 (64) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 14 |
| 1972 2 Sept | Round 22 | Hawthorn | 15.12 (102) – 18.13 (121) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 19 |
| 1972 10 June | Round 11 | St Kilda | 17.8 (110) – 7.14 (56) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 54 |
| 1971 25 Sept | Grand Final | Hawthorn | 12.10 (82) – 11.9 (75) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 7 |
| 1971 11 Sept | Semi-Finals | Hawthorn | 12.18 (90) – 12.16 (88) | St Kilda | MCG | Hawthorn by 2 |
| 1971 10 July | Round 15 | Hawthorn | 20.5 (125) – 15.12 (102) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 23 |
| 1971 24 Apr | Round 4 | St Kilda | 10.9 (69) – 18.19 (127) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | Hawthorn by 58 |
| 1970 1 Aug | Round 18 | Hawthorn | 11.11 (77) – 14.18 (102) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 25 |
| 1970 16 May | Round 7 | St Kilda | 10.21 (81) – 8.8 (56) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 25 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1969 30 Aug | Round 20 | Hawthorn | 14.17 (101) – 13.12 (90) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 11 |
| 1969 31 May | Round 9 | St Kilda | 14.11 (95) – 7.7 (49) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 46 |
| 1968 29 June | Round 11 | Hawthorn | 15.11 (101) – 17.9 (111) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 10 |
| 1967 5 Aug | Round 15 | St Kilda | 17.17 (119) – 8.8 (56) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 63 |
| 1967 6 May | Round 4 | Hawthorn | 10.6 (66) – 15.11 (101) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 35 |
| 1966 27 Aug | Round 18 | St Kilda | 14.9 (93) – 13.5 (83) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 10 |
| 1966 4 June | Round 7 | Hawthorn | 11.12 (78) – 15.12 (102) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 24 |
| 1965 26 June | Round 10 | St Kilda | 24.12 (156) – 11.9 (75) | Hawthorn | Moorabbin Oval | St Kilda by 81 |
| 1964 25 July | Round 14 | St Kilda | 11.15 (81) – 7.9 (51) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 30 |
| 1964 2 May | Round 3 | Hawthorn | 12.15 (87) – 9.11 (65) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 22 |
| 1963 8 June | Round 8 | St Kilda | 8.13 (61) – 9.11 (65) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 4 |
| 1962 25 Aug | Round 18 | St Kilda | 14.16 (100) – 9.11 (65) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 35 |
| 1962 4 June | Round 7 | Hawthorn | 9.8 (62) – 12.22 (94) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 32 |
| 1961 19 Aug | Round 17 | Hawthorn | 19.6 (120) – 14.7 (91) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 29 |
| 1961 27 May | Round 6 | St Kilda | 14.16 (100) – 12.9 (81) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 19 |
| 1960 18 June | Round 9 | St Kilda | 7.13 (55) – 8.19 (67) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 12 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1959 15 Aug | Round 16 | Hawthorn | 10.11 (71) – 5.5 (35) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 36 |
| 1959 23 May | Round 5 | St Kilda | 10.21 (81) – 11.11 (77) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 4 |
| 1958 28 June | Round 12 | St Kilda | 11.14 (80) – 14.14 (98) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 18 |
| 1958 12 Apr | Round 1 | Hawthorn | 11.14 (80) – 11.13 (79) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 1 |
| 1957 22 June | Round 10 | St Kilda | 10.15 (75) – 8.11 (59) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 16 |
| 1956 4 Aug | Round 16 | Hawthorn | 15.8 (98) – 12.9 (81) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 17 |
| 1956 12 May | Round 5 | St Kilda | 3.9 (27) – 6.12 (48) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 21 |
| 1955 25 June | Round 10 | Hawthorn | 12.9 (81) – 6.7 (43) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 38 |
| 1954 17 July | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 14.17 (101) – 5.10 (40) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 61 |
| 1954 24 Apr | Round 2 | St Kilda | 5.9 (39) – 10.10 (70) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 31 |
| 1953 25 July | Round 13 | St Kilda | 9.13 (67) – 4.14 (38) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 29 |
| 1953 2 May | Round 2 | Hawthorn | 8.9 (57) – 13.14 (92) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 35 |
| 1952 21 June | Round 9 | St Kilda | 5.11 (41) – 7.6 (48) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 7 |
| 1951 4 Aug | Round 14 | St Kilda | 11.8 (74) – 9.14 (68) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 6 |
| 1951 5 May | Round 3 | Hawthorn | 12.15 (87) – 9.10 (64) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 23 |
| 1950 15 July | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 10.11 (71) – 12.12 (84) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 13 |
| 1950 29 Apr | Round 2 | St Kilda | 20.24 (144) – 5.5 (35) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 109 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1949 2 July | Round 11 | St Kilda | 13.11 (89) – 14.13 (97) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 8 |
| 1948 4 Sept | Round 19 | Hawthorn | 7.12 (54) – 9.13 (67) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 13 |
| 1948 5 June | Round 8 | St Kilda | 7.12 (54) – 10.12 (72) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 18 |
| 1947 26 July | Round 15 | Hawthorn | 16.18 (114) – 10.9 (69) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 45 |
| 1947 10 May | Round 4 | St Kilda | 10.17 (77) – 12.12 (84) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 7 |
| 1946 22 June | Round 10 | St Kilda | 10.24 (84) – 9.12 (66) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 18 |
| 1945 21 July | Round 14 | Hawthorn | 15.15 (105) – 13.3 (81) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 24 |
| 1945 5 May | Round 3 | St Kilda | 15.10 (100) – 11.13 (79) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 21 |
| 1944 12 Aug | Round 15 | Hawthorn | 12.16 (88) – 12.16 (88) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Draw |
| 1944 27 May | Round 4 | St Kilda | 9.12 (66) – 11.7 (73) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 7 |
| 1943 8 May | Round 1 | St Kilda | 14.9 (93) – 13.17 (95) | Hawthorn | Toorak Park | Hawthorn by 2 |
| 1942 1 Aug | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 8.9 (57) – 10.15 (75) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 18 |
| 1942 16 May | Round 2 | St Kilda | 16.13 (109) – 9.17 (71) | Hawthorn | Toorak Park | St Kilda by 38 |
| 1941 12 July | Round 11 | Hawthorn | 13.12 (90) – 9.15 (69) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 21 |
| 1940 20 July | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 17.17 (119) – 8.15 (63) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 56 |
| 1940 4 May | Round 2 | St Kilda | 12.25 (97) – 7.13 (55) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 42 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 8 July | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 11.18 (84) – 15.17 (107) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 23 |
| 1939 22 Apr | Round 1 | St Kilda | 18.20 (128) – 9.13 (67) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 61 |
| 1938 25 June | Round 10 | Hawthorn | 8.12 (60) – 9.10 (64) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 4 |
| 1937 17 July | Round 13 | St Kilda | 11.15 (81) – 9.8 (62) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 19 |
| 1937 1 May | Round 2 | Hawthorn | 14.15 (99) – 15.22 (112) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 13 |
| 1936 11 July | Round 10 | St Kilda | 16.9 (105) – 12.16 (88) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 17 |
| 1935 10 Aug | Round 15 | St Kilda | 17.22 (124) – 9.9 (63) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 61 |
| 1935 18 May | Round 4 | Hawthorn | 6.17 (53) – 16.8 (104) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 51 |
| 1934 21 July | Round 11 | St Kilda | 13.10 (88) – 10.12 (72) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 16 |
| 1933 15 July | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 7.9 (51) – 8.15 (63) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 12 |
| 1933 29 Apr | Round 1 | St Kilda | 10.17 (77) – 11.13 (79) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | Hawthorn by 2 |
| 1932 30 July | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 8.13 (61) – 7.8 (50) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 11 |
| 1932 7 May | Round 2 | St Kilda | 16.19 (115) – 11.16 (82) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 33 |
| 1931 8 Aug | Round 14 | Hawthorn | 11.9 (75) – 11.11 (77) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 2 |
| 1931 16 May | Round 3 | St Kilda | 10.12 (72) – 10.8 (68) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 4 |
| 1930 3 May | Round 1 | Hawthorn | 16.7 (103) – 14.8 (92) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 11 |
| Year | Round | Home | Score | Away | Venue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1929 20 July | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 7.9 (51) – 15.12 (102) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 51 |
| 1929 27 Apr | Round 1 | St Kilda | 12.10 (82) – 8.10 (58) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 24 |
| 1928 7 July | Round 12 | St Kilda | 20.14 (134) – 12.13 (85) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 49 |
| 1928 21 Apr | Round 1 | Hawthorn | 9.13 (67) – 10.10 (70) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 3 |
| 1927 16 July | Round 12 | Hawthorn | 7.12 (54) – 8.11 (59) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 5 |
| 1927 30 Apr | Round 1 | St Kilda | 12.16 (88) – 11.2 (68) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 20 |
| 1926 4 Sept | Round 17 | Hawthorn | 10.10 (70) – 12.14 (86) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | St Kilda by 16 |
| 1926 5 June | Round 6 | St Kilda | 12.7 (79) – 6.14 (50) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 29 |
| 1925 8 Aug | Round 13 | Hawthorn | 8.11 (59) – 8.8 (56) | St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval | Hawthorn by 3 |
| 1925 9 May | Round 2 | St Kilda | 17.12 (114) – 8.12 (60) | Hawthorn | Junction Oval | St Kilda by 54 |
Includes every completed VFL/AFL game between the two clubs, home-and-away and finals.